![]() |
||||||
The world of cancer information |
||||||
|
Minutes of Meeting/Conference calls |
INTERNATIONAL CANCER INFORMATION SERVICES GROUP
|
| Present | Catherine Dickens (Chair) |
Cdickens@macmillan.org.uk |
| Doreen Akkerman |
Doreen.Akkerman@cancervic.org.au | |
| Cora Honing |
voorlichting@kankerbestrijding.nl | |
| Marion Morra |
morram@earthlink.net | |
| Monika Preszly |
m.preszly@dkfz.de | |
| Chris Thomsen |
thomsenc@mail.nih.gov | |
| Anne Vinkel |
avs@cancer.dk | |
| Claudia Di Loreto |
aimac@tin.it | |
| Anne Vézina |
avezina@cancer.ca | |
| Regrets | Mary Anne Bright |
brightma@mail.nih.gov |
| Hilke Stamatiadis-Smidt |
presse@dkfz.de | |
| Richard Epstein | daarje@nccs.com.sg | |
| Observers | David Manning – ICISG project coordinator |
|
| Carmel Quinn – Macmillan (September 1) |
||
| Ruth Carlyle – Macmillan (September 1) |
||
| Guests | Peter Cardy – CEO Macmillan (item 2.1) |
|
| Jasper Smith - Sparks (item no. 7) |
ACTIONS ARISING FROM THE MEETING
Presentation on cancer organizations
UICC conference
Logo design
Website
Achieving our goals
Sponsorship
Also see Action arising out of the Annual General Meeting September 1, 2003.
1. WELCOME AND INTRODUCTION
Catherine welcomed everyone and introduced the agenda for the meeting.
2. PRESENTATION - BOARD MEMBERS’ ORGANIZATIONS
2.1 Macmillan Cancer Relief, London, England
Peter Cardy, CEO of Macmillan Cancer Relief, congratulated the ICISG board
for its initiative and progress to date. He emphasized the key role of
ICISG in raising awareness for cancer information supported with adequate
resources and high quality service delivery. Mr. Cardy gave an overview
of Macmillan Cancer Relief:
• Founded in 1911 by Douglas Macmillan, whose father died of esophageal
cancer.
• Recognized need for financial assistance and provided goods instead
of money.
• Campaigned for improvements in treatment and cancer care. Developed
programs for nurses in palliative care and hospices.
• Over the years, Macmillan Cancer Relief raised capital costs for
more than 40 hospices.
• Implemented concept of senior specialist nurses working as an
educators. Three year seed funding is then supplemented by the National
Health Service (NHS) or host organization There are now more than 2000
nurses and 1000 healthcare staff today.
• Provides funding for cancer treatment centers and information
centers with NHS.
• Macmillan Cancer Relief acts as an agent for change. It raises
€120M from donations per year and is supported by 550 staff and 13,000
volunteers.
• Catherine mentioned that an evaluation of 10 cancer websites will
be published shortly. The results of the study will help define better
navigation practices for cancer information websites. Catherine will post
it on the listserv.
2.2 Anti-Cancer Council, Victoria, Australia
Doreen provided a summary of the various programs offered by the Anti-Cancer
Council:
• Based in Melbourne, it offers 14 core programs with 33 staff.
Programs include cancer information, support, living with cancer, speakers
bureau, cancer connect (parents and caregivers), look good feel better,
sexuality and financial assistance.
• Established service delivery standards and links with other states
in Australia
• Developed a communication skills workshop for healthcare providers
• Currently provides training for a CIS in New Zealand.
• Cancer Helpline responds to 50,000 inquiries/year and established
a multi-lingual service to answer inquiries in any of 200 languages.
• Involved in research project to test follow-up calls to cancer
patients.
2.3 Danish Cancer Society
Anne Vk is now working in advocacy programs on behalf of cancer patients:
• The communication skills training program is now compulsory for
graduating physicians (doctors to doctors).
• Developed a brochure on the availability of treatment options,
patient rights, second opinion.
• Created a leaflet on men support groups offered in the hospital
• Another brochure includes 20 psychosocial clinical practice guidelines
and recommendations based on published studies regarding the impact of
doctors’ behaviour and communications on patients.
• New website with cancer information also supports chat rooms (works
well for men with family member with cancer).
• Tested a “mobile” CIS to try to reach more men (40%
of callers after 3 years).
2.4 German Cancer Research Centre
Monika read a letter from Hilke announcing her retirement and resignation
from the ICISG Board. Hilke sent her best wishes and the Board acknowledged
her contribution to the CIS in Germany and to the ICISG.
Founded 20 years ago, the German Cancer Research Centre’s CIS is
funded by donations and the government. Monika explained how the German
Cancer Information Centre has to secure its niche due to political changes
and new competition, such as patients’ right to cancer information
and the requirement of insurance companies to provide cancer information.
• CIS has been in operations since 1996, and recently initiated
a breast cancer disease management program.
• Recently added a hotline on pain and fatigue (with Johnson and
Johnson)
• Writing brochures for the Cancer Center.
• Planning an information service for physicians as part of a comprehensive
cancer center funded by the Ministry of Education (includes email, internet,
training modules).
• Developed email service because of saturated phone lines
• Planning a user survey in the fall
2.5 Dutch Cancer Society
Cora gave an overview of the Dutch Cancer Society’s CIS:
• Established 25 years ago, it is operated by 30 staff
• Given the competition, the Dutch Cancer Society’s CIS is
looking at new strategies, policies and funding. Need to establish organization
as first place to go to find services in the community. Facing issues
of recognition and differentiation from government agencies and hospital
services.
• Integrating special programs for patient education (brochures,
phone, internet) and trying to raise awareness among young people.
• New program on spirituality and cancer.
• Recent campaign focused on cancer in the family. This included
promotion through door-to-door campaign, special activities, different
hours for CIS and a conference on heredity.
• Prevention messages are now enhanced by an interactive approach
on the internet
• Conducted a survey to find out cancer patients preference for
follow up information at home.
2.6 iMAC
Claudia explained that iMAC, founded in 1997, was the first organization
in Italy to provide cancer information. It is a member of the ECL and
advocates for patients rights (especially in the work place).
• Activities started with the production of booklets
• Government provides funding for support helpline with 2 psychologists.
• Cancer information desks are now located in 4 cancer centers.
• Funded a study in 20 cancer centers involving 380 patients to
assess the effectiveness of cancer education (verbal information only,
verbal +print, verbal + print + audio/video tapes). Claudia will post
the results of the study on the listserv, when completed.
2.7 National Centre on Complementary and Alternative Medicince,
US (NCCAM)
Chris explained that NCCAM is conducting rigorous studies on the effectiveness
of CAM. It is developing evidence-based information for patients, especially
cancer patients. NCCAM is collaborating with Macmillan; a new fellowship
in integrated medicine is funded by Prince of Wales Foundation. Other
key points included:
• NCCAM is focusing on the whole person, along the entire continuum
of care (not just after treatment).
• NCCAM conducted a survey on CAM information needs of cancer patients
(patients find CAM information from the internet or word-of-mouth from
other patients, they do not have tools to evaluate quality of information
and they do not talk to their physician). This survey will provide a baseline
for an education program and new tools to help cancer patients make decisions.
• NCCAM website has factsheets on CAM and cancer treatment, with
questions to ask on different therapies. Chris will send the link to the
listserv.
• CancerCare internet lectures provide easily accessible forum for
cancer education. Chris will post the link on the listserv. A lecture
on CAM will be webcast on October 6.
2.8 Marion Morra Consultant
After more than 20 years with the NCI, Marion left 6 years ago to become
a consultant. Her book for cancer patients “Choices” will
be published shortly. Marion observed that patients are overwhelmed with
too much information; quality and relevance are key. Her book includes
a section on searching on the internet. She expressed concern that the
US does not have a nation-wide cancer plan. In Mary Anne’s absence,
Marion gave a brief overview of NCI activities:
• NCI has a research consortium (with Al Marcus) to study how health
communication can impact behaviour (eg prevention) and how decision-aids
might help cancer patients with breast, prostate and colorectal cancer.
• NCI conducted a study on the type of service CIS callers might
like to receive (eg. email conversation, call back, help to navigate internet).
It was noted that internet users still call CIS. Marion will distribute
the results of the survey on the listserv.
A brief discussion followed on the need for a navigator role, human touch and the importance to provide a list of questions to ask the doctor.
2.9 Canadian Cancer Society’s Cancer Information Service
Anne Vz gave an overview of the CIS activities in Canada and presented
the results of the recent user survey. She indicated that a literature
review suggested a 90% level of satisfaction as the benchmark for this
type of service. The results were analyzed based on three client types
(cancer patients, family and friends and the general public). Several
survey questions focused on how participants were helped by their call
to CIS. The merits of “cost per call” were debated and all
agreed that this was not an appropriate metric to evaluate a CIS.
3. ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING OF THE ICISG BOARD
Refer to minutes provided under separate cover
4. ICISG FACULTY DEVELOPMENT AND COURSE PLANNING
Catherine indicated that the plans for the 2004 UICC conference were uncertain
and announced the dates for the 2006 UICC conference in Washington DC
(July 9-13, 2006). A discussion followed on various approaches to ensure
that ICISG is represented on the Planning Committee and is part of the
program (plenary and workshops). Catherine will inquire about the membership
of the Planning Committee for the 2006 conference. She will ask Robert
Burton if he would be the presenter for the ICISG plenary session. Doreen
and Catherine will lobby their contacts for a UICC conference to be held
in 2004.
Marion and Cora tabled a draft outline for proposed plenary and workshop sessions for the UICC conference. Comments were provided and each Board member will sign-up for a specific topic. It was agreed that Catherine, Marion and Cora will submit the course outline for track 3 and 4 of the 2006 conference. The 2004 conference, if not cancelled, will give us an opportunity to pilot test part of the course.
It was suggested that presenters would use a power point template with their respective logos and the new ICISG logo.
5. CIS HOW TO MANUAL
Marion distributed the last draft outline of the How To Manual. This will
be a web-based tool which will link to sources provided by ICISG members.
The main sections are:
• Contextual issues
• Conducting a basic overview assessment
• Determining the scope of services to be offered
• Writing a strategic plan
• Plan for building services
Marion and Mary Anne will update with comments and send an electronic copy to Anne Vz for pilot testing with Korean and French visitors.
6. ICISG LOGO & DESIGN
Chris presented the short list of proposed logos. Logo no. 4 was generally
preferred by the Board. Board members will discuss logo no. 4 with their
respective team and get back to Chris. Doreen will inquire about registering
the logo. Chris offered to draft logo guidelines (colour, black/ white)
and design a power point template.
7. ICISG WEBSITE
Jasper Smith, from Sparks, joined the meeting to present the new website
design. Catherine expressed appreciation on behalf of the Board for the
support generously provided over the years by Sparks, and especially by
Jasper. Jasper expressed interest in continuing to provide his services
and to host the ICISG website.
Jasper presented a quick view of the proposed new design for the website. Participants discussed the integration of the new logo and a site map. The search feature, drop-down menu for the list of members and the password bulletinboard will not be implemented at this time. It was agreed that the new URL www.icisg.org will be registered and remain accessible from the UICC website. Chris will supply picture of CIS information specialists. The ICISG email address was suggested as info@icisg.org. The listserv address will be provided for members. Doreen will send suggested disclaimer for linking to other websites and how to get back.
Anne distributed a draft outline for the content of the new website. The preliminary content will be developed further and new sections will be added (contact us, linking policy, disclaimer, home). Board members were reminded to send their bio with a picture. The membership list will include a brief overview of the organization (in English) with a link to the organization’s website for more information. It was suggested that CIS documents and tools not be made available directly from the ICISG website. Outside organizations should be encouraged to contact any of us for more information. Board members publications will be added (including abstract for past UICC conferences). A map with CIS links was suggested. Anne Vz will check key points for usability standards. The estimated launch date for the ICISG website is January 2004.
8. ACHIEVING OUR GOALS
Listserv
Following a brief discussion on the listserv and how little it is currentlyused,
Board members agreed to be more involved in posting CIS information on
the listserv. Mary Anne will submit the members list to Anne Vk, who will
communicate the latest instructions on how to subscribe/ unsuscribe. Anne
Vk will also cross-reference listserv subscribers with the ICISG members
list.
Exchange program
At this time, this initiative is considered of lower priority and will
be followed-up by Mary Anne and Anne.
Membership
It was agreed that we seek out new members, starting with UICC members.
An article in the UICC newsletter on ICISG might generate interest.
9. SPONSORSHIP PROPOSAL FOR 4TH CONFERENCE
Catherine tabled a draft sponsorship project proposal for 2006. The final
document will include an overview of ICISG. Suggestions for sponsorships
are:
• Preconference workshop
• Advance course during conference
• Exhibit package
• Travel for Faculty
• Travel expenses for organizations featured in case studies of
countries that have been helped.
Catherine will prepared the next draft of the sponsorship proposal. Doreen offered to approach the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation for an organizational grant.
10. OTHER BUSINESS
During the meeting, several topics were identified for future discussion:
• Pharmaceutical companies seeking affiliation with CIS in several
countries
• Sensitivity of providing cancer information while seeking donation
support.
11. NEXT STEPS AND ADJOURNMENT
Catherine encouraged each Board member to start following up on their
respective action before minutes are distributed. The meeting was adjourned
at 15:00 and followed by a visit of the Macmillan Cancer Relief offices.
Prepared by Anne Vézina, November 2003
Last Updated: 8 January 2008