Mission
Who we are
Our collaboration with UICC
What we do
President's Reports
Governance
Board of Directors
Working Groups
Minutes of Meeting/Conference
calls
 |
 |
INTERNATIONAL CIS GROUP
Board of Directors Meeting
April 23-24, 2007
AIMaC Offices, Rome
Attended by: Ingrid Aubry (April 23)
Mary Anne Bright
Francesco De Lorenzo (April 24)
Silvia Den
Catherine Dickens
Roshini George
Cora Honing (April 23)
Marion Morra
Monika Preszly
Chris Thomsen
Anne Vézina
Guest: Laura Del Campo (AIMaC)
Regrets: Doreen Akkerman
Ana Olivera
ACTIONS FROM THE MEETING
Governance
- Anne, Chris and Doreen will update the minimum standards and operation guidelines and review in Washington in September
- Anne to develop a workplan for May to August 2008
- Anne and Chris will revise wording of mission to clarify that ICISG’s mission is to “support”
- Chris will draft the 2006 annual report for posting on the website.
Strategic plan
- All directors will revise their section of the strategic plan based on comments from the meeting and submit to Anne and Chris for final editing by May 15.
Memberships
- Anne to follow-up with Irene regarding Russian course participants (and nurses)
- Anne and Irene will follow up with associate members to find out about progress toward starting a CIS.
Sponsorships
- Ingrid and Mary Anne will try to identify a foundation with an international focus
UICC World Cancer Congress
- Anne and Chris will develop the abstract for the plenary presentation
- Roshini will inquire about ACS sponsoring the ICISG AGM and reception
- Consider submitting an abstract to present results from survey of members of ICISG
- Silvia and her staff will help with materials and administrative support for the course and the exhibit.
CIS Course
- Roshini and Mary Anne will develop core categories for developing a budget for operating a CIS.
- Marion, Monika, Roshini will establish a working group and start developing the course Level 2.
Collaborations
- Anne and Chris will write Cora to express interest in collaboration ECL related to cancer information service.
- Cora will pursue inviting a ICISG representative to make a presentation at an ECL meeting.
- Cora will ensure that the ECL website has a link to the ICISG website.
- Anne and Chris will send an announcement to ECL re plans for UICC congress, article in ECL newsletter.
- Chris and Anne will ask Ana for UICC information on other cancer leagues that already exist, especially in Asia
- Anne will meet with Nancy Lins in May regarding ICISG potential role with ACS international.
- Roshini will inquire about the ACS survey results.
- Catherine will provide a contact name for Cancer Research UK
- Anne will contact NCI’s International Office
- Anne will ask Doreen if there are other cancer groups in Australia and South-East Asia
- Anne to look into AORTIC as a possible group with which to collaborate.
- Mary Anne and Roshini will explore potential link with Cancer Planet and ICISG.
ICISG Website
- Mary Anne will arrange to have a PDF of the ICISG article sent to Irene for posting on the ICISG website.
- Irene will review and update the list of cancer information websites in other languages
Communications / Publications
- Chris/Mary Anne to write a press release re workshop on clinical trials
- Marion will send the final version of the ICISG article to board members
- Roshini and Mary Anne to develop an abstract on CIS stats with ICISG members (10 question survey)
1. OPENING REMARKS
Anne V welcomed everyone and noted regrets from Doreen and Ana. On behalf of ICISG, Anne thanked AIMaC for their generous hospitality.
Anne gave an overview of the objectives for the meeting and the agenda was amended. The objectives are to:
1. Discuss the long term viability of ICISG
2. Review the strategic plan
3. Plan for UICC 2008, specifically course level 1 and level 2
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF MEETING
The minutes of the conference call of March 7 were approved without comments.
3. RELATIONSHIP WITH UICC
Anne indicated that the final version of the MOU between ICISG and UICC had been sent for comments to ICISG board members. No comments were received and the MOU was sent to UICC for signature. Anne and Chris will meet with Isabel Mortara in Geneva at the end of the week and sign the MOU to continue the UICC-ICISG collaboration.
4. ROUND TABLES WITH UPDATES FROM BOARD MEMBERS
Board members provide a brief update on their respective organization and CIS.
Cora / Dutch Cancer Society
- Changes to the CIS: moving toward a service targeted at cancer patients and their family only (will include early detection. Prevention inquiries will be referred to the website, audience tends to be younger (90% have access to internet).
- Implications on the information specialists and quality
- Moving away from print materials to web-based communications (web TV channel)
- Active in lobbying for prevention with the government, especially with tobacco control, working toward smoke-free public areas.
Monika / KID
- CIS is now fully integrated within the German Cancer Research Centre
- New toll-free number accessible everyday from 8am to 8pm throughout Germany, installed voice mail
- Affiliation with an organization to develop a promotion specifically for prostate cancer (marketing, print materials) because so few men are calling.
- New hotline for prostate cancer sponsored by an association dedicated to the promotion of cancer information in Germany (proKID e.V.)
- Started information fact sheets (eg. clinical studies, treatment options, HPV vaccination, community services, pain, financial assistance/insurance, how to search on the internet). These were distributed at a patient conference. Facts sheets are also available on the KID website.
Silvia / Swiss Cancer Society
- CIS staff by 7 nurses with German, Italian and French
- Topics range from prevention to palliative care
- CIS also organizes patient conferences
- Planning to develop fact sheets in 8 languages
- CIS also includes a team for the new tobacco cessation helpline, evaluation will be planned.
- Monday to Friday, 10am to 6pm
- Brochures are available as PDF on the website
- Received education grants from pharmaceutical companies for specific brochures.
Mary Anne / National Cancer Institute
- Reported on the clinical trials workshop funded by the Italian and American Ministries of Health.
- NCI wrote 11 articles that will be published in a Journal of Cancer Education’s monograph later this year. This includes a paper on ICISG.
- CIS budget has been reduced and Mary Anne is developing the next concept for the future. Mary Anne has recruited an advisory panel to help define the concept.
- Offices of CIS and education/special initiatives will be merging to become the Office of Communications and Education
- CIS and CDC have been working since 2004 to create a network of smoking cessation helplines which generated over 660,000 inquiries since its inception.
- CIS’s partnership program is very involved with ACS and CDC at the regional level in every state
- NCI is launching a new Spanish website, the Miami CIS office to respond to Spanish email.
Marion
- Marion was also a speaker from the US and from ICISG at the clinical trial workshop in Rome. She presented “What Patients Need to Know About Clinical Trials”.
- Marion is part of the CISRC team headed by Al Marcus conducting a research study with patients who call the CIS. Three projects will contribute to knowledge about decision-making related to breast and prostate cancer. Protocol will include sending a decision-aid on CD-ROM with/without a follow-up call from CIS.
- Marion has been involved in the JCE monograph to be published.
- Marion will be assuming the Chair of the American Cancer Society National Board in October.
- CDC has been funding each state in the US to develop comprehensive cancer control plans. The steering groups for these projects include representatives from the ACS, NCI and CDC (Leadership institute).
Ingrid / Institut national du cancer
- The CIS started by the Ligue de lutte contre le cancer has been taken over by the institute
- Inquiry process includes 2 levels (first level: information specialist for information, second level: support inquiries are transferred to the Ligue). Level 1 team does the triage for the Level 2 team.
- New team of 3 information specialists and one supervisor under going training
- CIS is aimed at patients and their families, Monday to Saturday 8am to 8pm
- Ingrid is overseeing the information database. Content written by members of the institute.
- Approximately 100 inquiries per day.
- CIS is part of the communications and public education department
Catherine
- Catherine informed the group of the recent changes in the UK cancer arena, specifically with Cancer Link and McMillan Cancer Relief, Cancer Bacup and Cancer Research UK.
- Catherine is doing consulting work for a Patient Information Forum in the UK
- Catherine is a trustee for the Sexuality and Relationship Therapy group.
Chris /NCCAM
- One year ago, Chris helped organized a workshop with AIMaC on complementary and alternative medicine.
- Chris has been working on an information campaign on CAM for the public. 66% of the population uses CAM, and 60%-80% of cancer patients. Cancer patients do not tend to discuss CAM with their doctors.
- The education campaign “Time to talk” with an “ask” (healthcare professional) and a “tell” (patient) campaign is being rolled out.
Laura/AIMaC
- New toll-free number Monday to Friday from 9AM to 7PM (phone, email).
- Information specialists (4) are mostly psychologists who provide support over the phone. The staff also includes an oncologist and a lawyer to help with legal issues, especially related to working conditions. There are still issues related to the lack of awareness on the new patient rights.
- 29 booklets are available on the AIMaC website.
- More than 1 million visitors to the AIMaC website last year.
- Opened 16 information points in the main cancer centres in Italy.
- The promotion campaign called “With the cancer, Against cancer” was recently launched.
- New website being launched regarding services in the community within Italy, with search tools. This resource will also be published and distributed to healthcare professionals. www.oncogouida.it
- AIMaC is funding scholarships in psycho-oncology, and is part of an initiative to reduce duplication and maximize synergy between cancer organizations in Italy.
- Laura gave an overview of FAVO, a federation of the 500+ volunteer cancer organizations in Italy, whose goal is to represent the interests of cancer patients to enhance their quality of life.
Roshini / American Cancer Society
- CIS call centres were consolidated into one a few months ago. CIS management is starting to look at strategic issues.
- Call volume has stabilized, callers are more informed and the topics are more complex.
- Inquiries are starting to focus more on end of life issues. ACS is developing some materials and the possibility of triaging to more experienced information specialists. Looking at operational efficiencies of the various approaches, including specialized training (e.g. clinical trials, health insurance).
- Information specialists are given responsibilities to work off-line or on special projects. ACS is developing an awareness campaign on the need for health insurance for cancer patients.
- Trying to promote CIS on the website as the web traffic continues to increase. A person can send an email to request CIS to call back at a specific time.
Anne /Canadian Cancer Society
- Reorganization of the national office, Anne’s portfolio is now Corporate and International Affairs. As she will be phasing out of her role as CIS national director, she will continue as the President of the ICISG.
- An external evaluation will start in May with a consultant and the new management model will arise from the results of the evaluation. ICISG board members may be contacted by the consultant.
- CCS print and web content are under the Cancer Control Policy department.
- CIS will participate in a research study which will follow the Australian study started a few years ago.
- CIS promotion will be targeted at healthcare professionals for referrals to cancer patients and family. Other initiatives include exploring collaboration with cancer agencies (registries) to reach recently diagnosed cancer patients.
- CIS will be conducting a user survey in October to assess the motivation for the use of CIS vs. other sources of cancer information, satisfaction, actions taken as a result of the call and overall impact.
- CCS adapted the sexuality brochure from Australia and is developing a CAM brochure based on the NCCAM’s brochure.
- Community service database interface was redesigned on www.cancer.ca
5. COLLABORATIONS WITH ECL AND ACS INTERNATIONAL
5.1 Collaboration with ECL
Cora provided an overview of the ECL and its membership. She explained that the size of the member organizations and their respective scope are varied. ECL has a head office in Brussels, with a small secretariat. The general assembly includes 29 members under the leadership of a board of 7 directors (with Cora as the President). Members pay a membership fee. The website will be launched in one month.
ECL leads lobbying efforts in cancer control on behalf of its memberships. Round tables have been initiated on topics of mutual interests such as relationship with pharmaceutical industry. ECL is also setting up initiatives for sun safety, early detection for colorectal cancer, HPV vaccine etc. - ECL is integrating patient support and patient information in one working group.
ECL had started to organize a cancer information service conference every 2 years with EU funding. Anne Vinkel from Denmark will lead the patient support working group. The ECL welcomes the exploration of potential relationship. The ECL board of directors agreed that ECL could facilitate a conference on cancer information service (with logistic support by ECL secretariat). This conference would be accessible by ECL and non-ECL members. Monika, Cora and Anne Vinkel will meet in Copenhengen in June to discuss further. ECL would also consider inviting ICISG members to their annual meeting.
Other possibility would be to focus the collaboration with ECL members who have a helpline. There might be a possibility to develop a MOU similar to the one with UICC. We could plan to have a joint meeting in Geneva in 2008.
Actions:
- Anne and Chris will write to Cora to express interest in collaborating with ECL in the next few years.
- Cora will consider inviting a ICISG representative to make a presentation at an ECL meeting.
- Anne and Chris will send an announcement to ECL re plans for UICC congress, article in ECL newsletter.
- Cora will ensure that the ECL website has a link to the ICISG website.
5.2 ACS international
Marion gave an overview of the ACS international group. A new strategic plan is being developed. ACS is looking to collaborate with groups like the ICISG that already offer specialized services. ACS is developing relationships with India, China and Mexico. ACS has identified a priority in the translation of cancer content.
Actions:
- Anne and Chris will ask Ana/UICC re other cancer leagues that already exist, especially in Asia
- Anne will discuss with Nancy Lins in May.
- Roshini will inquire about the ACS survey results.
5.3 Other collaborations
It was suggested that ICISG explore other potential collaborations.
Actions
- Anne will contact NCI’s International Office
- Anne will ask Doreen if there are other cancer groups in Australia and South-East Asia
- Anne to look into AORTIC as a possible group with which to collaborate
6. ICISG SUSTAINABILITY
Anne gave an overview of the proposed brainstorming exercise to identify key factors regarding ICISG sustainability and to propose recommendations for future directions.
The group was asked to consider:
Who we are:
- Strengths
- Weaknesses
- Threats
What we do:
- Our mission in the last 10 years
- Our mission until 2015
- What benefits or impact do we make
- How we delivery value
Resources:
- What are potential sources of funding
- What would be funded
- Various structures to receive funding
- Current resources within ICISG
Possible governance model for ICISG
- Financed organization
- Status quo
- Association with membership fees
Ideas were recorded on flip charts as per appendix A and the recommendations were:
Recommendations:
- Proactive recruitment of ICISG board members from organizations with resources/capacity (expand diversity)
- Explore UICC funding for hosting visiting countries/ICISG travel to countries
- Explore pharma sponsorship for courses
- Post annual report with ICISG/accomplishments on the web site
- Recruit our own CIS staff to develop the course – international group to develop Geneva course under our leadership. English/French staff.
- Explore the German/US Annelies Schlich scholarship support travel for two staff to attend UICC Geneva
- Seek sponsorships/scholarships through UICC or directly
- Explore the implication for charging a course fee at conference
7. STRATEGIC PLAN
Anne and Chris provided an overview of the status of the development of the strategic plan. Board members were asked to give an overview of their respective sections and to provide comments to ensure that we capture the essential points, that there is consensus on the proposed direction and to identify additional points needed to complete each section.
Purpose and audience (Chris and Anne)
Purpose
- Focus for work of ICISG for 2007-10
- Document to explain what ICISG is about
- Basis for annual report
- Roadmap for our work
- Help identify opportunities for growth and take action
- Provide a document to facilitate discussion for collaboration and sponsorship
- Great reference document for our membership, sponsorship, succession.
Audience
- ICISG members and potential members
- Potential collaborators and sponsors
- Internal and external audience
Overview (Mary Anne)
- Need for preamble to tie-in the mission/objectives of ICISG to the strategic directions of the strategic plan
- Emphasize importance of information as part of quality cancer care
- Refer to publications on the importance of cancer information for patients
- Vision should include more about ICISG’s vision – include the one-on-one information delivery and how it helps decision-making
- Mention in-kind support from member organizations
Action: Anne and Chris will revise wording of mission to clarify that ICISG’s mission is to support
Partnerships and collaborations (Cora)
Cora was not present and suggestions for inclusion of this section were:
- Preamble about the importance of collaborations, benefits and the types of partners ICISG is looking for
- Collaborations with UICC, ECL, ACS international
- Background of UICC relationship and goals, MOU
- Objectives for ECL collaboration
- Exploring collaborations with ACS international
- Identify other cancer associations in other parts of the world
Memberships (Monika, Silvia)
- Add a preamble about the importance to develop the membership of ICISG
- Overview of ICISG membership (types, number, countries)
- Clarify that organizations are the members but can have many representatives
- Mention the value and benefits to members (refer to expertise section)
- List Board liaisons with specific geographic area, developing countries
Recruitment strategy:
- Look at UICC membership survey
- Look at UICC conferences in various continents
- Recruit membership from ECL members who have a CIS
Relationship with members
- Membership package (pamphlet, pin…strategic plan??)
- Communication tools between members (listserv)
Expertise on starting a CIS (Marion, Roshini, Ingrid)
- Add a preamble
- Strategic directions should be focused on how ICISG provides expertise/type of expertise
Suggestion for course/promotion
- Explore CancerCare (www.cancercare.org) for partnership to provide web/telephone educational a course on cancer information (what is needed, how much does it cost)
- Find a sponsor for a CIS course (UICC, ACS international) -
- Topic would be on how to find quality cancer information.
- Explore translation of ICISG introduction/overview materials in other languages (French, German, Spanish, Italian)
- Think about how ICISG could assist with advocacy efforts from a cancer organization to seek funding to start a CIS in their countries.
- Comments on 3.4: consultancy from any members, not just board members
Sustainability (Chris, Catherine)
- Add a preamble about need for sustainability
- Keep on-going concern of revisiting the format and secretariat functions
- Focus on what makes ICISG unique
- Fiscal agency concept (see comments from yesterday’s discussion)
- Section should move to Part C of the strategic plan
- Sponsorship: identify a foundation with an international focus (Ingrid/Mary Anne to search)
- Specify that ICISG will seek funding for projects
- Develop a menu of projects/costs for which we could seek funding
- Explore grant opportunities
- Advisory group – take out “scientific” focus on senior advisors (influential, international community who can support the promotion of CIS around the world e.g. David Hill, Tom Kean). Do not create another group, but inviting someone with reputation to join ICISG to a meeting to provide strategic advice to ICISG
- Secretariat: describe secretariat , acknowledge support from other organizations, fiscal agent
Promotion of ICISG (Chris)
- Add Cancer Care web/telepconference
- Add Patient Forums organized by UICC
- Promotion items are the costly items of ICISG, which dictates the limit of our promotion initiatives
- Add the pins
- Develop media section on ICISG website with canned article for other organizations newsletter (ECL, UICC, AIMaC)
- Add PDF of the brochure, stock photos, press releases when recruiting new members, contacts
- Develop a media list and distribute
- Think about including testimonials (start a CIS section??)
Knowledge transfer (Mary Anne)
- Feasibility of conducting research projects, comparative analysis
- Comparative user surveys
- Dissemination of research of findings through publications
- Potential study to identify the use of internet vs. telephone to demonstrate the value of CIS (one on one by phone, email)
- Ideas for publications: Impact of CIS on user
Profile of CIS in the world.
Provide information on clinical trials
- Identify journals that would be suitable for ICISG publications
- Look at what has been in one of our organization, and what could be duplicated in other organizations.
Governance (Anne)
- Describe the infrastructure, secretariat
- Vision/mandate (include the one-to-one relationship)
- Finite numbers of CIS??
- Quality assurance; discuss minimum standards and operations guidelines
- Board of directors, include ex-officio board members
- Advisory group/champions
- Include sustainability section
- Succession strategies
Course curricula (Marion, Roshini)
- Expanding the faculty through the CIS staff of affiliated board member organizations (info specialists)
- From these, we can tailor to shorter course (e.g. Cancer Care format etc…)
- See discussion below for draft course curriculum.
8. UICC WORLD CANCER CONGRESS 2008 - UPDATE
Suggestion for plenary: to demonstrate the benefits of CIS to research
Suggested speakers: Al Marcus and David Hill
Actions:
Anne and Chris to develop the abstract for the plenary presentation
Consider submitting an abstract to present international results from members of ICISG
Silvia will help with copying course materials and administrative support for the course and the exhibit.
9. COURSE, PART II – ADVANCED (MARION)
Marion distributed a handout with the proposed course outline
Discussion/suggestions:
- More advanced topics, more interactive
- Pre-conference, morning plenary and afternoon concurrent sessions (beginning/advanced in the afternoon.)
- Round table discussions with 2 faculty worked well
- More time for questions and answers
- Look for topics with highest feedback on 2006 course presentations
- Improve on exercises or leave out exercise, do not do report back to the group
- Limit attendance to 35 plus faculty
Morning session – theater style
Presentations
- What is a CIS
- Overview of ICISG
- Demo of web-based toolbox
- Lessons learned – case study (e.g. Flora Yong, Singapore)
- Faculty for the day
Afternoon beginner – round tables
- Needs assessment
- Sample call and call elements
- Staff models and basic training
Afternoon advanced- round tables
- Staffing issues and quality assurance
- Content and resources
- Management
Actions:
Create working group to be led by Marion, Roshini, Monika plus IS from organizations (CCS, ACS, KID, NCI, Swiss Cancer Society, Dutch Cancer Society)
- Develop an outline for the course
- Update the tool box, add new examples.
- Develop discussion guide for the Faculty at the round tables
- Power point presentations
- Administrative support re pre-registration, list of participants, coordination of facilities, AV requirements.
10. DISCUSSION WITH PROFESSOR DE LORENZO RE PATIENT SERVICES
Dr. De Lorenzo led a discussion on patient services and gave advice to ICISG:
- Explore collaboration with cancer patients groups to discuss advocacy efforts on behalf of cancer patients.
- Raise awareness about CIS to Eastern European countries (collaborate with ECPC).
- Explore opportunities to apply for project grants for ICISG (Laura and Monika) to help with ICISG initiatives.
Action:
Prof. De Lorenzo will send the article about clinical trials between AIMaC and NIH.
11. TOOL BOX – UPDATE (Chris)
Chris gave an update on the visits of the toolbox – 38 visits, especially by India, Malaysia, Japan. South Korea.
12. ICISG AND INTERNATIONAL CANCER CONTROL (Mary Anne, Roshini)
Mary Anne introduced Cancer Planet to Board members and explained how research results are submitted to the Planet database for evidence-based programs
Actions:
Mary Anne/Roshini will explore link with Planet and ICISG.
13. MEMBERSHIPS (Anne)
Anne reported that ICISG recruited 4 new members in the last 12 months (Brazil, Kenya, Nigeria and Sweden).
Anne asked Board members to update the group on their follow-up correspondence with organizations who participated in the CIS course in 2006.
- Roshini/Mary Anne followed up and received replies from Peru
- Catherine/Doreen: no replies received to date
- Silvia/Monika: sent follow-up but received no replies
- Anne: no replies
A discussion followed on the role of board member as liaison.
Action:
Anne and Irene will follow up with associate members to find out about progress toward starting a CIS.
14. OTHER BUSINESS
Email
Board members shared how they respond to international email, respond to questions and provide links. This would be a topic for Board education at the next in-person meeting.
Action
Irene will review and update the list of cancer information websites in other languages
ICD code
The discussion on use of ICD codes for consistency was deferred until Doreen is present.
15. NEXT CONFERENCE CALL AND ADJOURNMENT
The next conference call will be held on June 14 at 8 AM EST.
The meeting was adjourned at 4 PM.
Last Updated: 8 January 2008
|